Laserfiche WebLink
Historic Preservation Commission <br />Meeting Minutes <br />January 9, 2017 <br />Page 8 of 14 <br />Cyndi Thomas runs through the architectural criteria. <br />a. Architectural. <br />(1) Exemplifies specific elements of an architectural style or period. <br />(2) Example of the work of an architect or builder who is recognized for expertise <br />nationally, statewide, regionally, or locally. <br />(3) Demonstrates superior craftsmanship or high artistic value. <br />(4) Represents an innovation in construction, materials or design. <br />(5) Style particularly associated with the Louisville area. <br />(6) Represents a built environment of a group of people in an era of history that is <br />culturally significant to Louisville. <br />(7) Pattern or grouping of elements representing at least one of the above criteria. <br />(8) Significant historic remodel. <br />The home meets #5 and #6. I think we should be careful on this. Without spending funds for an <br />assessment, it is clear in my mind that you could spend well in excess of grant funds available. <br />Chuck Thomas says I agree with you in terms of cost. I would expect it to be well in excess of <br />the cost of the demolition. <br />Fahey makes a motion to place a 180 day stay on demolition on the structure at 1436 Cannon <br />Street, during which time the property owners can present mor • formation and have the stay <br />reviewed, seconded by Chuck Thomas. Roll call vote. <br />Name <br />Vote <br />Lynda Haley <br />Yes <br />Mike Koertje <br />Yes <br />Debby Fahey <br />Yes <br />Cyndi Thomas <br />No <br />Chuck Thomas <br />Yes <br />Caleb Dickinson <br />Yes <br />Motion passed/failed: <br />A <br />Motion passes 5-1. <br />Najera asks if we can get the HPC to look at the se before we do any more investigation. <br />Trice says we can discuss next steps. I will b t, ch. We have the design assistance option <br />with the HPC. <br />Dickinson says he will volunteer to help the app5Ticant. <br />Chuck Thomas says he will volunteer as well to help the applicant. <br />PUBLIC HEARING — 840 McKinley Avenue Demolition, Demolition #HIP -000017-2016 <br />A request to demolish the structures at 840 McKinley Avenue. Reviewed by a subcommittee on <br />December 16, 2016. <br />Conflict of Interest and Disclosure: <br />Cyndi Thomas has a previous financial relationship with the applicant that will not impact my <br />decision making. <br />Staff Report of Facts and Issues: <br />Trice presents from Power Point. <br />LOCATION <br />• Constructed in 1934 <br />• Associated with Helburg/Callahan/Brugger family for over 60 years <br />ARCHITECTURE <br />• Four gable roofs <br />