Historic Preservation Commission Agenda and Packet 2020 08 17

Home Browse Search

Historic Preservation Commission Meeting Minutes June 8, 2020 Page 2 of 4 Andy Johnson, DAJ Design, spoke as the applicant. He noted the quantity and quality of the original materials that remain on the house. Public Comments: None Discussion: Parris commented that the structure seems to meet all the criteria for age, significance, and integrity. Klemme agreed. Parris made a motion to recommend approval of the Probable Cause finding and the $4,000 Historic Structure Assessment Grant. Klemme seconded. Passed unanimously by voice vote. 541 Jefferson Avenue: HSA Presentation Andy Johnson, DAJ Design, presented the following information regarding the HSA completed for 541 Jefferson Ave. Johnson commented on the changes that have occurred to the house over time. A major renovation was completed in 1997 that moved the house on the lot to comply better with zoning and also changed the fagade to include the addition of a bay window. Proposed changes to the house as a result of the HSA include: removal of stucco siding; removal of front door; removal of replacement windows; repair or replace wood siding and trim; add an historically appropriate front door; add historically appropriate windows and trim. Klemme asked for clarification on the window at the rear of the house. Johnson confirmed its location over the stairs. Haley asked about the addition located on the front of the house and if there was any conversation regarding reverting to its original appearance. Johnson commented on the changes that occurred to the house over time including door and window relocation as well as the original materials that may remain on the structure. Parris commented on the possibility relocating the front door to its original location. Johnson responded that the relocation wouldn't be feasible based on the current layout. Klemme commented on the extent of the 1997 and that it doesn't comply with the Secretary of the Interiors guidelines for renovations. Hayley commented on the importance of differentiating the materials and design on new additions from historic portions of a property. Subcommittee Updates Klemme discussed the video she's developing to provide an overview of the historic preservation program. She also discussed a shared spreadsheet for the HPC members. Selvoski responded that a maximum of two commissioners can work on any specific document; documents can be shared with the full commission for discussion at an HPC meeting. Klemme asked how commissioners could evaluate properties in an objective way. 2 3