Historic Preservation Commission Agenda and Packet 2020 10 19

Home Browse Search

Historic Preservation Commission Meeting Minutes 21 September 2020 Page 2 of 5 Haley asked if the lot would be subdivided. Selvoski responded that the lot would not be subdivided but it eligible for a second dwelling unit. Dunlap asked if the lot was large enough to be subdivided and Selvoski stated that it was not. Klemme asked about the design of the porch and if the design was historic. Selvoski responded that the porch was rebuilt but the design is historic. Andy Johnson, DAJ Design, spoke as the applicant. He noted the original character that the house has retained over time. He clarified that the porch that exists today retains the original roof structure; at some point in the past the front porch was enclosed but was later returned to the form that exists today. He also clarified that no alterations were being proposed to the historic structure at 633 La Farge. The property may undergo alterations with the proposed relocation of 1201 Lincoln but the landmarked structure itself will not be altered. Public Comments: None Discussion: Dunlap clarified that if we landmark the structure as opposed to the property, the HPC would not be able to weigh in on future changes to the property. Staff confirmed that. Chair Haley stated that going through the alteration certificate procedure in this case showed that the HPC reviewed the proposed change against the alteration certificate requirements. Klemme commented that she was excited to see the property begin the historic preservation process and that the structure seems to meet all the criteria for age, significance, and integrity. Haley agreed, and noted that it's exciting to possibly so many homes in the same area participating in the preservation program. Dunlap noted that the houses along Pine were all built by the same carpenter. Parris agreed that this was an excellent candidate for probable cause. Klemme made a motion to recommend approval of the Landmarking and the $5,000 Landmark Incentive grant. Dunlap seconded. Passed unanimously by voice vote. Keller clarified that this property was eligible for a second dwelling unit. Selvoski responded that this was allowed in the RM zone district in Old Town with lots of a certain size. Haley commented that the size and scale of the structure to be relocated to the property is sensitive and appropriate. Dunlap agreed, and appreciated being able to review this proposed change. Dunlap made a motion to approve the Alteration Certificate for 633 La Farge. Parris seconded Passed unanimously by voice vote. 1201 Lincoln Avenue: Landmark, Alteration Certificate, Grant Staff presented the following the research and information on 1201 Lincoln Avenue: The house at 1201 Lincoln Avenue was built in 1908 and shows elements of the Craftsman - inspired style common in early 20th century Louisville. The residential structure was associated with the Koci/Reddington family for 80 years. Staff found that the structure had maintained l►i