Historic Preservation Commission Agenda and Packet 2022 03 21

Home Browse Search

Historic Preservation Commission Meeting Minutes February 21, 2022 Page 2 of 9 NEW BUSINESS — PUBLIC HEARING ITEMS 7A. Demolition Request — 620 Garfield Avenue: A request to release the demolition permit for the existing principal structure and accessory structures at 612 Jefferson Avenue. A subcommittee referred the request to the Historic Preservation Commission because they found probable cause to believe that the property may be eligible for designation as a landmark. • Applicant: ArcWest Architects • Case Planner: Kim Bauer, Historic Preservation Planner All notice was met as required and there is no commissioner conflict of interest. Staff Presentation: Bauer begins her presentation by showing an aerial image of the property, reviewing the historic conditions, and displaying what the current view is of the property. The purpose of the demolition review is to prevent loss of buildings that may have historic and architectural significance; and provide the time necessary to initiate designation as an individual landmark or to consider alternatives for the building. She mentions the four review criteria: 1. The eligibility of the building for designation as an individual landmark (age, significance, integrity). 2. The relationship of the building as a potential contributing structure to a potential historical district. 3. The reasonable condition of the building. 4. The reasonable projected cost of restoration or repair. She then reviews the age, significance, and integrity of the home. The principal structure at 620 Garfield Avenue was constructed in 1950 making it 72 years old. The significance of this house is that it is associated with the historic development of Louisville and the expansion of the residential area immediately surrounding downtown. It shows the growth of the Louisville Heights subdivision and a long history with the Barclay family. In regards to the home's integrity, this structure adds character and value to Old Town and remains on its original lot in the Louisville Heights subdivision. It is also a representation of a changing and growing Old Town, as more mid-century styled homes were constructed. The structure remains in its original location and has not been moved. In conclusion, the property retains all seven aspects of integrity including location, setting, workmanship, materials, design, feeling and association. Staff Recommendations: Staff recommends approval of a 75-day stay from the date of application, expiring on February 27, 2022, giving the applicant time to research alternatives to demolition as well as pursue a historic structure assessment. Commissioner Questions of Staff.- 3