Historic Preservation Commission Agenda and Packet 2022 10 17

Home Browse Search

In 1948, the Boulder County Assessor had photos taken of houses in Louisville and information was filled out on a card for each house, with follow up visits when modifications were being made that would change the tax assessment. Here are the photo of the house and a sketch of the layout from that card. However, it appears from the card that the photo, instead of dating from 1948, instead dates from 1950, 1951 or 1955, which are all dates indicated on the card as being when the Assessor returned to make additional notes on the card. A notation says to "send old pic" (presumably the one that had been taken in 1948) to Maggie Africh, who was the new owner starting in 1954. The card indicates that the blue pencil markings for the existing layout were done in 1948 and the red pencil markings, showing an addition on the south side of the original building, were added at the time of one of the County Assessor's return visits in the 1950s. After Milo's death in 1954, Maggie Sparks Vinson Africh bought the property. It was then purchased by Harold and Rosemary Bennett in 1981 before being purchased by the current owner and applicant in 2000. Previous Demolition Requests In 2007, the property owner (and current applicant) applied for a demolition permit for the structure along with three other structures. At that time, a subcommittee of the HPC found that "the three homes and garage in question were unlikely to qualify for landmarking and therefore, the Subcommittee agreed to release the demolition permit." No further information is available on the subcommittee's reasoning. The demolition was never completed and the HPC review expired with the building permit application. In 2009, a Planned Urban Development (PUD) was approved for the surrounding area, including Lot 3 on which the subject structure sits, and included the following notation: "Existing single story framed house. To be demolished upon completion of townhomes on lot four." This demolition requirement was lifted by City Council Resolution 15, Series 2013 at the request of the applicant. This PUD amendment also increased the allowed density of the development by one additional dwelling unit. ARCHITECTURAL INTEGRITY: The easternmost structure at 555 County Road is a one-story, wood -frame house with a rectangular floor plan and a projecting front porch. In the "Stories in Places" Louisville residential context, it is listed as a National structure, a nineteenth-century form of folk housing present in the city. It appears to exhibit characteristics of different National forms, including gable -front and hall -and -parlor. With multiple doors on the house shown in the 1948 Assessors Card photo, it is possible that the structure combined multiple forms or added door locations and orientations over time. The structure retains a high level of integrity given that the exterior and footprint appear to be largely changed since the 1948 Assessors Card and 1950s edits (see Historical Background section above for more information on the dates of the Assessors Card notations). The southeast elevation appears to remain largely, if not completely, unchanged, as does the footprint of the house. Based on street -view images of the house, it appears that the applicant removed the majority of the siding sometime after June of 2021 without a demolition permit or demolition review. The removed siding has exposed what appear to be larger openings on the north side of the house, suggesting that the structure has undergone changes to window (or door) size/location since its construction. However, the Assessors Card shows that the southern windows from circa 1948 remain in place and that the front -facing elevation also remains largely, if not completely, unchanged. The building permit file shows a permit for construction in 1967 for a "patio" and roof repair for hail damage in 2010. No other changes are reflected in the building permit file. 10