City Council Minutes 2012 11 20 - Laserfiche WebLink

Home Browse Search

City Council Meeting Minutes November 20, 2012 Page 7 of 15 Council member Jasiak asked if the application was denied, could the applicant resubmit his application. City Attorney Light confirmed the applicant could re-file his application, but noted the application cannot be denied yet provide conditions that guarantee future approval. PUBLIC COMMENT Mr. Poppitz asked if he would be reimbursed. He wanted to reroof, reside and install custom windows and totally restore the exterior. He would not request HPC funds for the home's interior. Michael Menaker, 1827 Choke Cherry Drive, Louisville, CO concurred with staff's recommendation. He did not feel the home had the architecture integrity. He agreed the social history is more important than the structure. He urged support for staff's recommendation. Council member Keany inquired about the retroactive repayment. Planning Director Russ stated the code does not allow for reimbursement for a structure improvement prior to landmarking. Council member Loo voiced her appreciation of the people who came forward in support of landmarking this home. She noted the City will make significant financial contributions to the Grain Elevator and suggested a higher standard for HPC funds. MOTION: Mayor Muckle moved to approve Resolution No. 76, Series 2012, seconded by Council member Yarnell. Council member Keany asked if there is an ability to make retroactive payments. Planning Director Russ agreed the applicant may reapply, but the Louisville Municipal Code does not allow for funds to be saved or set aside for a home which could be landmarked in the future or reimburse a home that is not currently designated as a landmark. Mayor Pro Tem Dalton stated it was not a matter of money, but about landmarking worthy properties. Council member Yarnell agreed it was not about money, but felt this is significant because of the neighborhood piece. Council member Jasiak asked Mr. Stewart whether there are better examples of other miner homes. Mr. Stewart confirmed there are better examples of the miners' homes. VOTE ON THE MOTION: The vote was 3 —3. Council members Yarnell, Jasiak and Mayor Muckle voted yes. Mayor Pro Tem Dalton, Council members Loo and Keany voted no. Absent: Council member Sackett. A tie vote results in denial of the motion to approve Resolution No. 76, Series 2012.