Historic Preservation Commission Agenda and Packet 2020 10 19

Home Browse Search

Historic Preservation Commission Meeting Minutes 21 September 2020 Page 3 of 5 much of its physical integrity; the fagade of the house has undergone minor changes over time including changes to the siding as well as the addition of stone to the front porch but retains significant architectural integrity when viewed from the street and appears to be in good condition for its age. Staff finds that the structure met the landmarking criteria and recommended approval of the landmark request as well as the name Koci House. Selvoski also presented the alteration certificate request allowing the relocation of the structure to 633 La Farge Avenue. While the relocation of historic structures is generally not a preferred method of preservation, staff believes it is the only method of preserving 1201 Lincoln Avenue and is therefore allowable in this situation. In addition to relocating the structure, the alteration certificate also allows for the reconstruction of the front and rear porches. Staff recommends approval of the alteration certificate for the property at 1201 Lincoln Avenue allowing it to be relocated to 633 La Farge Avenue. Selvoski presented the grant request for a matching grant in the amount of $85,000 and a finding of extraordinary circumstances. She reminded the Commission that without extraordinary circumstances, the maximum grant amount was $40,000. Selvoski noted that the proposed work was eligible for coverage. Selvoski stated that staff found that the original grant request included funds for City fees, however those expenses are not eligible for historic preservation funds. The applicant altered their request to remove that item. Staff recommends approval of the grant request in the amount of $85,000. Andy Johnson, DAJ Design, spoke as the applicant and presented on the current status of the house and it potential relocation. He noted the quantity and quality of the original materials that remain on the house. The front porch has been altered and the house is missing some detailing that can be replaced. Johnson mentioned that the chimney may need to be removed prior to the relocation. He also discussed Louisville's history of relocating structures to and within the city. Johnson confirmed that the proposal does meet the zoning requirements in regards to parking, setbacks, lot coverage and will not require any variances. Levi Sheppard, owner of 633 La Farge Avenue, stated that the move was scheduled for the second week in October (tentatively) and that they're very excited about saving a piece of Louisville's history. Dunlap asked what the plans were regarding the front porch. Andy Johnson responded that the plans were to return it to the original Craftsman -style porch. Public Comments: Dan Berlau, current owner of 1201 Lincoln, stated that he and his wife are excited about participating in this process and the possible relocation. Discussion: Haley commented that the structure meets the requirements for landmarking and has undergone minimal changes. The structure is proposed to be relocated which means it will lose a tie to the property, but is less of a loss than a complete demolition. Parris responded that regardless of the property where this structure is placed, it meets enough of the criteria to be eligible for landmarking. 3