Historic Preservation Commission Agenda and Packet 2023 09 18

Home Browse Search

Historic Preservation Commission Page 2 of 5 record. Brackett Hogstad noted one further point: that it is unknown when the two garages on property were constructed and whether they are associated with the other structures. Also, 555'/2 was built after 1955 so is not considered specifically in the demolition review. Staff Findings: These structures meet the review criteria based on age, significance and architectural integrity. Staff received on emailed public comment in support of the demolition. Staff Recommendation: Staff recommends approval the 421 East Street demolition review request. Staff is not recommending a stay on the application, since no additional time is needed for reconnaissance. Staff and the applicant have reached the end of what is possible for a stay. Social history is an insufficient reason for a stay alone. Commissioner Questions of Staff. No questions. Applicant Presentation: Andy Johnson, DAJ Design, has no formal presentation, only a few comments. He mentions that the cabins are well preserved, albeit wrapped in asbestos. Johnson is not the architect for the re -development, but has been consulting for the applicant. The applicant is currently processing the third round of PUD comments on the planning review. He says that the applicant is ready to move with the demolition to make way for the new development. Johnson has gotten to know the Lombardi family who previously owned the properties and sold to his clients. He states that Bernie Lombardi no longer has emotional attachment. He hopes that in the end this will provide some good new housing opportunities for Louisville. Question of Applicant: Anderson asks how long Johnson been consulting; Johnson says 16 months. Dalia asks if any extension was provided on either of the previous demolition reviews. Johnson replies that he does not think that extensions are possible for demolition reviews. Public Comment: Tracy Black, resident, shared her story of renting one of the East St cabins since May 2023. When she moved in, she was not aware of the project. She likes the eclectic nature of the neighborhood and thinks it is tragic that it will be erased. As a professional working for the school district, she wants to continue to be able to live in Louisville. She is concerned about the affordability of the other townhomes in the area. She hopes that she will at least be able to finish out the school year at her rental, and is worried that her landlord will break the lease. 3