Historic Preservation Commission Agenda and Packet 2012 10 15

Home Browse Search

Historic Preservation Commission Meeting Minutes September 17, 2012 Page 2 of 9 Watson asked if he needed to recuse himself because he lived in the area. Robinson stated this was a pre-filing conference and no action is required, therefore recusal is not required. Stewart stated he believed there is architectural integrity of this structure which could make it eligible for landmarking. He said this structure would not lend itself to a historic district due to the fact that all of the surrounding houses being relatively new. Lewis stated this structure was the only old structure in the area and this structure has a lot of integrity. The structure appears to have the original windowsand layout. Eileen Colby, owner, stated the structure has had about 4 or 5 additions. She added the entire structure is sinking. Lewis stated, in general, the more the structure is original the more likely the subcommittee may call it up for a formal review. Colby gave a detailed description of the additions which have happened over time. Lewis gave a breakdown of what a subcommittee is and then explained what design assistance is. Robinson then gave a detailed breakdown of how long a demolition review can take. Stewart added even though the property is outside of the Old Town Overlay District and not eligible for local funds, it could be eligible for State tax credits. Public Hearing – LandmarkRequest – 1036 Walnut Street Robinson presented the staff’s report for the grant request. He stated the social history was not considered strong,nor did the structure appear to have architectural significance unique to the Louisville area even though the form appears to not have changed since 1948. Most of the historic materials have been removed. He concluded staff is not recommending approval of this landmark request. Fasick asked if the house was located within the area of influence. Robinson answered in the affirmative. Steve Poppitz, owner, disclosed his previous HPC involvement, and then presented some background facts of the house. He gave additional social history of the house, giving insight on the previous owners not included in the background history. He stated this house is the quintessential miners shack and gave an update of all of the improvements. He added the interior of the house is in very good shape. Poppitz recommended creating a walking tour based on Edith Guenzi’s walk from her house to the St. Louis Parrish.