Historic Preservation Commission Agenda and Packet 2014 02 10

Home Browse Search

Historic Preservation Commission Meeting Nlinutes January 13, 2014 Page 7 of 11 McKinley stated it was discussed but never pursued. Echohawk asked if the house could be reoriented on the lot. Stewart stated it could be possible. La Grave stated he was compelled by the applicants statements the cost to save the structure would be unreasonable. He stated the addition behind the existing structure would be overbearing. He stated he is leaning towards releasing the permit. Haley stated she believes it is worth having a discussion with a design consultant. Stewart agreed and stated he would rather exhaust all options. Eric Finstra, realtor for the project, stated he agreed with La Grave stating retention of the structure would not be in the best interest for this property. Stewart stated there are several factors we put into our decisions. The demo review is more speculative because we have to look at the potential for landmarking. Finstra stated there are other structures being presented tonight which have more eligibility than this structure. The addition put on this structure is approximately 50% of the size of this house. Haley stated we also look at social history as well, and your house has a strong social history. La Grave addressed Finstra by stating each property is dealt with on a case by case basis and the outcome may be based on other circumstances. Watson made a motion to release the demolition permit because the structure would be costly to retain and might be enveloped by a large addition. Echohawk seconded the motion due to lack of future significance. Motion to release the demolition permit approved 5 to 2. Haley and Stewart voting no. Discussion — 2014 Goals Stewart introduced the item, stating these are goals to be presented to City Council at a study session. Robinson stated the study session has been moved to March 11th. Watson voted to push this item until the next meeting. La Grave agreed. Stewart asked for volunteers to work on the goals.